Re: [$ieee-1850] Draft D7 (cleanup based on IEEE tech-editor comments)

From: Johan Alfredsson <johan.alfredsson_at_.....>
Date: Tue Apr 12 2005 - 08:27:50 PDT
Hi all,

Quickly browsing the LRM, I stumbled upon a couple of things that look
suspicious.

1) Looking at page 116, it seems that the Parametrized_Property
    nonterminal lacks the (FL_Property) part (cf. the Parametrized_Sequence
    nonterminal on the same page, and box 6-55).

2) In Box "Syntax 6-77" on page 89, Param_Type ::= Sequence is obviously
    wrong. It should at least incorporate "property", "sequence", "hdltype"
    "const" and the ones in Boolean_Type.
        What is the purpose of the Boolean_Type nonterminal?

3) Page 90: The SystemVerilog flavor example uses a "{" instead of the
    correct "(" in the definition of slope_is_1

4) Page 75: The first example of informal semantics of "for".
    The example uses "{" and "}" around an FL_Property F, while
    box Syntax 6-55 says it should be "(" ")".

5) Page 76: The rest of the examples completely lacks delimitors (no "{"
    "}" or "(" ")").

Regards,

Johan Alfredsson             Mobile:       +46 706 39 12 58
Software Architect           Direct:       +46 31 745 19 07
Jasper Design Automation     Office:       +46 31 745 19 00
Arvid Hedvalls Backe 4       johan.alfredsson@jasper-da.com
411 33 Göteborg, Sweden      www.jasper-da.com


On Tue, 12 Apr 2005, Harry D.Foster wrote:

> http://www.eda.org/ieee-1850/docs/IEEE-1850-PSL-DRAFT-Apr-11.pdf
>
> Best regards,
>
> -Harry
> ---
> Harry D. Foster
> Chief Methodologist           
> Jasper Design Automation
> http://www.jasper-da.com
> Tel: +1 650.966.0239     Cell: +1 650.804.5000
>
Received on Tue Apr 12 08:27:54 2005

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Tue Apr 12 2005 - 08:28:04 PDT