Minutes of the April 10, 2004 SV-BC Meeting (Design Modeling Committee) 12 Day 06 00 Month 54 00 Year 44 a- Matt Maidment - Intel aa Brad Pierce - Synopsys aa Karen Pieper - Synopsys aa Johny Srouji - Intel -- Dan Jacobi - Intel aa Dave Rich - Synopsys a- Francoise Martinolle- Cadence -- Jay Lawrence - Cadence -- Dennis Brophy - Mentor aa Mark Hartoog - Synopsys aa Rishiyur Nikhil - Bluespec -a Cliff Cummings - Sunburst Design Review Meeting Minutes Dave moves that we accept the meeting minutes. Nikhil seconds. No opposed. Matt abstains. Passes. Action Items: ============= Brad to investigate issue 12 Needs fixing/closing Dave to investigate issue 13 Close as a duplicate Brad to investigate issue 20 Fixed by LRM 58 Mark to investigate issue 24 Needs discussion Dave to investigate issue 25 Coverd by sv-bc 105 Meeting Minutes: ================ David's web links no longer work because of Karen's rework of the issues pages. Karen will take an action to fix it. Nominations are open for individuals who helped significantly with the development of a standard. Two to five sponsors from other companies are required for nominations. The deadline is 5/14 (this Friday). Nikhil, Johny, Karen all nominate Brad. Nikhil to write it up. Matt, Nikhil, Johny all nominate Dave Rich. Matt will write it up. Johny, Mark, Nikhil all nominate Matt. Mark will write it up. Johny, Brad, Nikhil all nominate David Smith. Johny will write it up. One meeting after this one remains before the standard is likely to be moved to the IEEE. New Action Items: 12: For arrays of interfaces, the indexing goes after the interface name. For generated modports, the index would go after the modport name. Because of this Dave moves that we close 12. Brad seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. 13: Dave moves that we close as a duplicate of 3.1a issue 176. Karen seconds. No opposed. NO abstain. Passes. 20: Brad moves that we close this issue as fixed by LRM 58. Dave seconds. No opposed. NO abstain. Passes. 24: Mark moves that we defer this issue to the IEEE SV process. Karen seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. 25: Dave moves that we close this isseu as SV-BC 3.1a issue 105. Karen seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. 27: Nikhil moves that we close this issue. Dave seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. 28: Dave moves that we close this issue as addressed in the 3.1a LRM. Karen seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. 29: Dave believes that the text in Section 30 of the 3.1a LRM makes an ascii dump mechanism obsolete. Karen believes that either we should expand VCD or deprecate it. Either way we should defer it to the IEEE SV process. Karen moves that we defer this issue to the IEEE SV process. Brad seconds. No opposed. NO abstain. Passes. 30: Brad moves that we defer this issue to the IEEE SV process. Karen seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. 31: This is an enhancement not an errata. Karen moves that we defer this issue to the IEEE SV process. Brad seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. Karen will update the issue to be marked as an enhancement. 32: Brad moves that we defer this to the IEEE SV process as an enhancement request. Dave seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. 33: Dave moves that we close this issue as addressed by issue 38. Brad seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. 35: Dave will make a proposal. 36: Same proposal by Dave should fix 35 and 36. 41: Message 1735 will be created as issue 41. Dave moves we accept this proposal. Brad seconds. No opposed. No abstain. Passes. Message 1731: This discussion is not preceded by an Errata marking. Message 1697: Francoise will send a mail starting "Errata" to indicate the issue. Message 1738: Brad will take a look to see if there is an issue. New action items: Karen will make the issues pages work with David's web links. Brad will investigate message 1738 to determine if there is an issue. Dave will make a proposal for 35 and 36. Meeting adjourns. Our next meeting is 05/24/04 at 9am Pacific.