While quadratic probing does indeed eliminate the primary clustering problem, it places a restriction on the number of items that can be put in the table--the table must be less than half full. Double Hashing is yet another method of generating a probing sequence. It requires two distinct hash functions,
The probing sequence is then computed as follows
That is, the scatter tables is searched as follows:
Since the collision resolution function is c(i)=ih'(x), the probe sequence depends on the key as follows: If h'(x)=1, then the probing sequence for the key x is the same as linear probing. If h'(x)=2, the probing sequence examines every other array position. This works as long as M is not even.
Clearly since c(0)=0, the double hashing method satisfies property 1. Furthermore, property 2 is satisfied as long as h'(x) and M are relatively prime. Since h'(x) can take on any value between 1 and M-1, M must be a prime number.
But what is a suitable choice for the function h'? Recall that h is defined as the composition of two functions, where . We can define h' as the composition , where
Double hashing reduces the occurrence of primary clustering since it only does a linear search if h'(x) hashes to the value 1. For a good hash function, this should only happen with probability 1/(M-1). However, for double hashing to work at all, the size of the scatter table, M, must be a prime number. Table summarizes the characteristics of the various open addressing probing sequences.
probing sequence | primary clustering | capacity limit | size restriction |
linear probing | yes | none | none |
quadratic probing | no | M must be prime | |
double hashing | no | none | M must be prime |