Subject: Re: Meeting minutes for the SV-CC Committee, Nov 20th, DRAFT
From: Michael Rohleder (michael.rohleder@motorola.com)
Date: Mon Nov 25 2002 - 04:57:56 PST
Hello Swapnajit,
thanks a lot for providing the attendance. I wanted to take over this list into the minutes and found some things that rather
confused me, therefore I take this chance to ask you:
?1) An additional column got added in front of the list, when you compare it with the list from the Nov, 5th (shown as the first
column below). The header below shows this with a 'V'; what is the reason for this column???
?2) When I compare the three columns added with the attendance from the Meeting minutes from Nov, 7th, Nov 19th and Nov 20th
(columns a,c,d) I found some differences (namely Stuart, Ghassan, and Joe Daniels).
?3) What should we do with Nov 12th?
Could you please clarify ???
Regards,
-Michael
Legend:
a) face-to-face Nov, 7th (taken from minutes sent out by Ghassan)
b) Unknown attendance from Nov, 12th -- attendance retrieved from minutes by people speaking or said not to be attending. All others
filled with ?
c) Minutes Nov, 19th (taken from minutes)
d) Minutes Nov, 20th (taken from minutes)
Nov, 5th 2002
list---------------------V vvv a b c d
[-xxxxxxx--] Yatin Trivedi ASIC Group [--xxxxxxx-----] - ? - -
[----xxx-x-] Tarak Parikh AT HDL [-----xxx-x----] - x - -
[-xx-xxxxx-] Francoise M Cadence [--xx-xxxxx-xxx] x x x x
[xx--xxxxx-] Stuart Swan Cadence [xxx--xxxxx-x-x] - x - x
[-----xxxxx] John Amouroux Mentor [------xxxxxxxx] x ? x x
[-----x--xx] Emerald H Mentor [------x--xxx--] x ? - -
[----xxxxx-] John Stickley Mentor [-----xxxxx-xxx] x - x x
[----------] Duane ?? Mentor [-----------x--] x x - -
[-----xxx-x] Doug Warmke Mentor [------xxx-xxxx] x ? x x
[-xx-xxxxxx] Michael R Motorola [--xx-xxxxxxxxx] x x x x
[xx-xxxxx-x] Kevin Cameron National [xxx-xxxxx-xxxx] x ? x x
[----------] Tayung Liu Novas [x-------------] - ? - -
[xxxx-xxxxx] Bassam Tabbara Novas [-xxxx-xxxxxxxx] x ? x x
[----xxxxxx] Swapnajit M SGI [-----xxxxxx-xx] - x x x
[-x----xx--] Darryl Parham Sun [--x----xx-----] - ? - -
[xx-x------] Simon D Synopsys [xxx-x---------] - ? - -
[x-xx------] Peter Flake Synopsys [xx-xx---------] - ? - -
[xxxxxxxxxx] Joao Geada Synopsys [xxxxxxxxxxxxxx] x ? x x
[xx-xxxxxxx] Ghassan Khoory Synopsys [xxx-xxxxxxx-xx] x ? x x
[xxxx-xxxxx] Andrzej L Synopsys [xxxxx-xxxxxxxx] x x x x
[--x-xxxx-x] Alain Reynaud Tensilica [x--x-xxxx-x---] - ? - -
[-----xxx--] Mike McNamara Verisity [x-----xxx--x--] x ? - -
[---------x] Kurt Takara 0-in [----------x---] - ? - -
[----------] Dave Rich ? [-----------x--] x ? - -
[----------] Joe Daniel (LRM Editor) [------------xx] x ? x x
Swapnajit Mittra wrote:
> On Wed, 20 Nov 2002 20:18:04 +0100 Michael Rohleder <michael.rohleder@motorola.com> writes:
> > Hi all,
> > here are the draft meeting minutes. [...]> -Michael
> [...]
> > Rolling attendance list will be generated by Swapanjit, since
> > attendance from the previous meetings was not yet updated before the
> > last meeting minutes. I hope this is the best way to avoid
> > confusion. Rolling attendance: This is what I have from Yatin, Ghassan and my own notes. 11/20 is included in this, but
> 11/12 is not. Yatin Trivedi ASIC Group [--xxxxxxx-----]
> Tarak Parikh AT HDL [-----xxx-x----]
> Francoise M Cadence [--xx-xxxxx-xxx]
> Stuart Swan Cadence [xxx--xxxxx-x-x]
> John Amouroux Mentor [------xxxxxxxx]
> Emerald H Mentor [------x--xxx--]
> John Stickley Mentor [-----xxxxx-xxx]
> Duane ?? Mentor [-----------x--]
> Doug Warmke Mentor [------xxx-xxxx]
> Michael R Motorola [--xx-xxxxxxxxx]
> Kevin Cameron National [xxx-xxxxx-xxxx]
> Tayung Liu Novas [x-------------]
> Bassam Tabbara Novas [-xxxx-xxxxxxxx]
> Swapnajit M SGI [-----xxxxxx-xx]
> Darryl Parham Sun [--x----xx-----]
> Simon D Synopsys [xxx-x---------]
> Peter Flake Synopsys [xx-xx---------]
> Joao Geada Synopsys [xxxxxxxxxxxxxx]
> Ghassan Khoory Synopsys [xxx-xxxxxxx-xx]
> Andrzej L Synopsys [xxxxx-xxxxxxxx]
> Alain Reynaud Tensilica [x--x-xxxx-x---]
> Mike McNamara Verisity [x-----xxx--x--]
> Kurt Takara 0-in [----------x---]
> Dave Rich ? [-----------x--]
> Joe Daniel (LRM Editor) [------------xx][...] > B) Swapanjit reminded the DWG that Nov, 26 is last date for
> > accepting issue filings
> > [Clarification request from Michael:
> > Is this deadline only related to issues about DirectC or also for
> > issue w.r.t. the other interfaces (assertion, coverage)?] Only for DirectC. For details, please see
> http://www.eda.org/sv-cc/hm/0311.html
> [...]> G) Swapanjit proposed to vote also on Kevin's and Johns proposal (Is
> > this correct, I thought it is from Joao and John S. ??? Or do I
> > think about a different proposal here?) Francoise, Andrzej and Joao
> > requested some more time to read it, think about it and
> > discuss it in the next call. Agreed. The proposal is from Joao and John S. I mentioned that at that time, Kevin and John
> were discussing this over emails.
> --
> Swapnajit Mittra
> Project VeriPage ::: http://www.angelfire.com/ca/verilog
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b28 : Mon Nov 25 2002 - 04:58:27 PST