FW: [sv-cc] [Fwd: P1800 instructions for editor - mantis 734, 709, 711 and 712]

For some reason, this bounced back this morning as
hung up for four hours, so except for Charles, you
all may not have received it.  And you may then have
properly been puzzled about what typographical errors
I was talking about.

Regards,
Jim V.

--------------------------------------------------------- 
James H. Vellenga                            978-262-6381 
Engineering Director                   (FAX) 978-262-6636 
Cadence Design Systems, Inc.         vellenga@cadence.com 
270 Billerica Rd 
Chelmsford, MA 01824-4179 
"We all work with partial information." 
---------------------------------------------------------- 
  

-----Original Message-----
From: Jim Vellenga 
Sent: Wednesday, May 18, 2005 10:02 AM
To: Neil.Korpusik@sun.com
Cc: SV-CC; Charlie Dawson
Subject: RE: [sv-cc] [Fwd: P1800 instructions for editor - mantis 734,
709, 711 and 712]

Neil,

Was the Pre-postponed region also added to the bulleted
list that serves as the third paragraph of 15.3?  I didn't
see that in the proposal for 712.

In the paragraph about the Postponed region, I believe
that the "Observe" region should actually be the "Observed"
region.

In the NOTE attached to the paragraph about the Post-observed
region, the spelling of "schcedule" should be corrected.

In the paragraph after that, should "Pre-Postponed" be
written as "Pre-postponed" instead for consistency with
other regions that have prefixed names?  I.e., don't
capitalize the first "P" in the suffixed "postponed"?

I notice that the proposal for 712 updated Table 15-3
so that cbEndOfSimTime now points to the "Pre-Postponed"
region (should that also be "Pre-postponed"), but that
cbReadOnlySynch still maps to the "Postponed" region.
Is that intentional?

Regards,
Jim Vellenga

--------------------------------------------------------- 
James H. Vellenga                            978-262-6381 
Engineering Director                   (FAX) 978-262-6636 
Cadence Design Systems, Inc.         vellenga@cadence.com 
270 Billerica Rd 
Chelmsford, MA 01824-4179 
"We all work with partial information." 
---------------------------------------------------------- 
  
 

] -----Original Message-----
] From: owner-sv-cc@eda.org [mailto:owner-sv-cc@eda.org] On 
] Behalf Of Charlie Dawson
] Sent: Tuesday, May 17, 2005 9:56 PM
] To: Neil.Korpusik@sun.com
] Cc: SV-CC
] Subject: [sv-cc] [Fwd: P1800 instructions for editor - mantis 
] 734, 709, 711 and 712]
] 
] The SV-CC will meet tomorrow and look at this set of changes.
] 
]    -Chas
] 
] 
] -------- Original Message --------
] Subject: P1800 instructions for editor - mantis  734, 709, 711 and 712
] Date: Tue, 17 May 2005 18:51:09 -0700
] From: Neil Korpusik <Neil.Korpusik@sun.com>
] Reply-To: Neil.Korpusik@sun.com
] To: chas
] CC: Mehdi Mohtashemi <Mehdi.Mohtashemi@synopsys.com>,        
] Arturo Salz <Arturo.Salz@synopsys.com>,        Stuart 
] Sutherland <Stuart.Sutherland@sun.com>,        Karen Pieper 
] <Karen.Pieper@synopsys.com>
] References: <42850689.4010702@Sun.COM> <428508FE.10602@cadence.com>
] 
] Hi Chas,
] 
] Arturo pointed out that Mantis item 712 also touches the same 
] text of the
] LRM. I have merged the text portion of that mantis item into 
] this same file.
] For mantis item 712 I made the same 2 wording changes in 
] order to make it
] consistent with the other paragraphs.
] 
]      "is specifically for" ---> "provides"
]      "for user code"  ---> "PLI application routines"
] 
] 
] Each of these text substitutions has been approved for a subset of the
] paragraphs by one of the committees.
] 
] The svec approved the following in mantis items 709 and 711
] (but not 712 nor 734).
] 
]      "is specifically for" ---> "provides"
] 
] The svcc approved the following in mantis item 734 (but not in 712).
] 
]      "for user code"  ---> "PLI application routines"
] 
] It would probably be good if the svcc voted on these 
] additional changes to
] ensure that all of them were approved by one of the committees.
] 
] Note that there are a couple of other changes mentioned in 
] mantis item 712
] that are not shown in the attached document. They modify 
] table 15-3 and
] figure 15-1. The modification to table 15-3 supercedes svcc 
] mantis item 372.
] 
] 
] Neil
] 
] 
] 
] Charles Dawson wrote:
]  > Hi Neil et All,
]  >
]  > I took a look at these changes, and they seem okay to me.  
] I will bring it
]  > up at our next SV-CC meeting (Wednesday) anyway.  I do 
] want to point out that
]  > Mantis Item 372 also deals with this section.
]  >
]  >    -Chas
]  >
]  >
]  > Neil Korpusik wrote:
]  >
]  >>Hi Chas, Mehdi, Arturo, Karen and Stu,
]  >>
]  >>Both the svec and the svcc have approved mantis items that 
] touch the same
]  >>paragraphs of the P1800 LRM.
]  >>
]  >>   svec - mantis 709 and 711
]  >>   svcc - mantis 734
]  >>
]  >>Since mantis item 734 is the one with the highest number, 
] Stu would typically
]  >>apply this set of changes last. If he uses this algorithm 
] some of the changes
]  >>contained in mantis 709 and 711 will be lost.
]  >>
]  >>Attached is a pdf file that contains the text that should 
] result after
]  >>merging all three of these mantis items.
]  >>
]  >>After merging the text for these I noticed there there 
] were a few places where
]  >>wordsmithing done in one paragraph was not made to the 
] same phrase in another.
]  >>I took the liberty of making all of these consistent. 
] There were only two
]  >>phrases affected by this change:
]  >>
]  >>   "is specifically for" --> "provides"
]  >>   "allows for" --> "allows"
]  >>
]  >>Other than those minor changes this should be an exact 
] merge of the three
]  >>mantis items.
]  >>
]  >>I am expecting that we will all be in agreement on this 
] and that it won't be
]  >>necessary to hold a joint conference call with the svec 
] and svcc to approve
]  >>this.
]  >>
]  >>Let me know what you think. This merged pdf may need to be 
] added to one of
]  >>the existing mantis items (734?).
]  >>
]  >>Neil
]  >>
]  >>
]  >>BTW - I will be on vacation for the rest of the day and 
] won't see any email
]  >>until Monday.
]  >>
]  >>
]  >
]  >
]  >
] 
] -- 
] ---------------------------------------------------------------------
] Neil Korpusik                                     Tel: 408-720-4852
] Staff Engineer                                    Fax: 408-720-4850
] Frontend Technologies - ASICs & Processors (FTAP)
] Sun Microsystems
] email: neil.korpusik@sun.com
] ---------------------------------------------------------------------
] 
] 
] 
] -- 
] Charles Dawson
] Senior Engineering Manager
] NC-Verilog Team
] Cadence Design Systems, Inc.
] 270 Billerica Road
] Chelmsford, MA  01824
] (978) 262 - 6273
] chas@cadence.com
] 
] 
]